We are working on a survey of NephJC and I am trying to wrap my mind around what are the most important questions to ask. I really want to know how well NephJC compares as an educational experience to "In Real Life" journal clubs Thinking about that lead to this discussion on Twitter:
NephJC afterparty
Some of the best NephJC discussions come after the hour long chat and can be off topic.
A red letter day for the GMT chatters
With a healthy bump in participants post #ERAEDTA15, just compare the participants. 'Nuff said.
The American chat
The GMT chat
PD/CHF: GMT chat storify
As promised, the GMT chat storify is here, complete with the after party discussion on diuretics. Another superb curation by Hector!
Hector does the Storify for American PD/CHF chat
Hector Madariaga - Nephrology Fellow from Syracuse and #NSMC intern - has now joined the #NephJC team. And you can see that why with the excellent job he has done with the storify of last week's chat. Watch this space for more contributions.
NephJC: GMT chat slightly delayed this week
In case you were all wondering where the EU/African leg of the PD/CHF #NephJC chat disappeared, it will be held - albeit with a week's delay - on Wednesday June 3rd. It is all for a good reason. It has been quite busy for the Europeans this week - as you must have seen with all the furious tweeting from Charlie Tomson, Daniel McGuinness, David Arroyo, and many more including our very own Paul Phelan (who also wrote some excellent AJKD blog posts).
But, better late than never - and we hope many of you join us this week for the PD/CHF #nephjc chat.
Nice article on tweeting the meeting
Add this to the two articles by Alex Djuricich to flesh out your live-tweeting medical library.
Solid turnout and great chat for: AKI Alerts
The author and a number of AKI scientists joined NephJC Tuesday night to discuss F. Perry Wilson's study.
Need any more evidence that #NephJC rocks?
You may have seen the evidence pyramid before, with animal studies and case reports at the bottom, and systematic reviews on the top.
Well, an interesting paper was published a few days ago, in the Journal of Medical Internet Research. Go ahead, click on that link and check it out.
It is a systematic review of all twitter-based journal clubs (and they seem to have captured all that were existing at that time). They have then examined the impact of these journals clubs using many different metrics. Interestingly, the one that immediately stands out is in table 2:
Table 2 from Roberts et al, http://www.jmir.org/2015/4/e103/
There's only one journal club with over a million impressions. Take a bow, all of you who have ever participated in a #NephJC chat!
The paper does make for interesting reading, apart from what we mention above. Some of the analyses agrees with our thoughts after the first dozen #nephJC chats.
Tonight's #Act4Kidneys Chat. Join us at 9 PM EDT
The chat begins at 9PM EDT, in just an hour. The topics will be:
- Topic Zero: What is an advocacy day? What can law makers do to help kidney patients and the field of nephrology?
- Topic one: 20 million Americans have kidney disease. The NIH spends only $29/patient. This is low compared to heart disease and cancer. Why is that?
- Topic two: One of the primary asks of #Act4Kidneys is The 21st Century Cures. What is this? What will this do for patients? What will this do for investigators.
- Topic three: The other ask for the "CKD Improvement in Research and Innovation Act" what is this and what will it do for our patients.
- If we are not going to the hill this week, what can we do to support these initiatives. Should we throw money at anyone? Call people?
From the ASN Advocacy and Public Policy page:
On Thursday, April 23 in Washington, DC, dozens of ASN members are heading to Capitol Hill to talk with Congress about important policies related to kidney patient health and kidney research.
Join their ASN Kidney Health Advocacy Day efforts by asking your members of Congress to support newly introduced kidney legislation – the Chronic Kidney Disease Improvement in Research and Treatment Act of 2015 (H.R. 1130, S. 598).
This bill will address key needs for patients with kidney disease: eliminating barriers to transplantation, improving our understanding of kidney failure in minority populations, and investing in life-saving kidney research.
Join ASN in calling on Congress to support this important, bipartisan bill now. Click here to send a message to your members of Congress asking them to sign onto this vital legislation.
click the image to down load the 21 page house version of the bill.
Here is the House Committee on Energy and Commerce website about the 21st century cures.
What not to do when you are the medical director
If it wasn't from the pages of the New York Times I wouldn't believe it.
Please join us on #NephJC, Tuesday at 9PM EDT and Wednesday at 8PM GMT for a discussion of proper medical director behavior.
The NephJC 23 (warfarin) American chat Storify - and analytics
It was pretty well attended...
So was the GMT chat next day...
and the GMT chat storify of NephJC 22
Nikhil does the BK storify
So our NSMC intern, Nikhil Shah not only did a super job of writing the sumary up for the BK virus #NephJC 22, he also has done a great job of curating the first chat into a storify.
NephJC 22: GMT chat
The American chat (mostly by virtue of its longevity) still has more participants and tweets, but the GMT (EU/African) chat makes up by being fun and entertaining. Tom Oates, Paul Phelan, Francesco and their merry band of tweeters make for delightful reading. Jungle Juice, scud missiles and more. See some highlights below
#NephJC number 22 is in the can.
The BK nephropathy discussion was interesting. No one was interested in further exploring quinolone for BK, which I guess indicates that this was a compelling study.
All and all it was a very interesting discussion and I learned a lot.
Storify forthcoming.
Palliative care chat #HPM on Wednesday at 9EST
March is Kidney awareness month and in honor of that, Pallimed, the Hospice and Palliative Care Blog is talking about intersection of nephrology and palliative care. They asked NephJC co-creator, Joel Topf to host their chat. This happens on Wednesday. Topf wrote the introduction:
Have you ever read a journal article and as soon as you finished the abstract you had this forbidding feeling that if the authors actually proved what they claimed to have discovered your medical life will never be the same?
This happened when I read, Functional Status of Elderly Adults before and after Initiation of Dialysis by Tamura et al. in 2009.
The study simply looked at mortality and functional status of nursing home residents who initiated dialysis. The cohort consisted of 3,704 Americans. The average age of this predominantly white (64%) female (60%) cohort was 74 years. The outcomes were horrifying:
- Within three months of starting dialysis 61% had died or had a decrease in their functional status
- By one year that figure was 87%
- By one year only 1 in 8 patients had maintained their functional status from before dialysis
While this study did not track patients who deferred dialysis it is hard to imagine they could do much worse. The view of dialysis as a way to improve functional status by clearing uremia leading to improved nutrition and other downstream benefits was revealed to be a false hope. Instead we have a treatment that appears to be too rough for frail, at-risk patients and left them significantly worse than they were before dialysis.
The discussion section of the article had a sentence that should be embroidered to every nephrologists white coat:
“...kidney failure may be a reflection of terminal multiorgan dysfunction rather than a primary cause of functional decline, and thus the initiation of dialysis may not rescue patients from an inevitable decline.”
As nephrologists we need to elevate conservative, non-dialytic, therapy to be a clear option for patients, one that should be discussed along with peritoneal dialysis and transplant. Conservative care should not merely be a last resort when all other options have been exhausted.
I hope you will join us as we discuss the intersection of nephrology and palliative care this Wednesday at #hpm chat.
from NephJC live to the Lancet
You might remember Perry Wilson, the young dapper nephrologist from Yale who presented his trial on AKI alerts at NephJC live a few months ago. He was tweeting as @nephrolalia - and has now renamed and rebranded himself as @methodsmanmd, which is quite apt given his recent blog posts and succinct and snappy videos up at MedPage Today.
More notably, the data he presented at #NephJC live has been published today - with some great additional analyses, in the Lancet. We sure know how to pick winners - so the next time we come calling, pick up the phone!
Tweet of the Week: Urine Eosinophils and NephroCheck
Dr. Faubel nailed the best comment about NephroCheck by reminding us while we pick apart the particulars of NephroCheck that we have some other dragons to slay:
And then Edgar slides in with the appropriate #NephPearl (How does he do that so fast?)
#NephJC 20: Who checks the checkers? Storify Part 1: EST chat
Last night we were off to a rollicking start with a great #NephJC chat - in great part due to the participation of Azra, Jay and Sarah! Joel took no time - burning the candle at both ends to do some storifys.
Here is the entire unedited archive with all the tweets from both chats:
Topic 0: Introduction, and How we do diagnose AKI?
Topic 1: Discussing DISCOVERY, SAPPHIRE and TOPAZ
Topic 2: ROC Curves and Diagnosing Aki with Nephrocheck
Topic 3: What happens now?
The GMT chat today was also very intense - Storify will follow shortly!